5 Top Online Stock Brokers

Posted by Blain Reinkensmeyer on Thursday May 31, 2007

New and experienced traders alike should always be on the prowl for good, better, and the best online stock brokers to trade with. The best brokers aren’t always the cheapest though, as this list will exploit. Just because you can get cheap trades doesn’t mean you are going to have the tools necessary to trade successfully.

(stats pulled from online brokers)

1. TD Ameritrade

TD Ameritrade is my favorite only be default since I have used them for several years. What you need to know about TD Ameritrade in a nut shell is this:

  • Flat-rate $9.99 commissions
  • 13,000+ mutual funds
  • Apex which I will explain more below
  • Award Winning Customer Service

I have used their Apex service (which is their elite traders account type) for a few years now and it has been nothing short of amazing. You get all of your service fees wiped which means everything that other brokers charge ya with for regarding your account are free with Apex. You also get hooked up on the research side as you get more of their services for free. Streamer, level II quotes, advanced analyzer, etc. Top it off with award winning customer service and you got a grand package. They also bought out TD Waterhouse last year (Vice the TD now in front of Ameritrade). They were voted #1 by Barron’s for the 2007 review of online brokers, have over 6 million clients, and are publicly traded under the stock symbol AMTD.

(Side note: I get $5 flat fee trades with them now as well, if you want to know how read my review of TD Ameritrade Izone)

2. Scottrade

Scottrade is well known for their customer service, which is represented by the who knows how many awards they have won. They boast 290 local branch offices in the United States, and also have flat-rate commissions of $7 per trade. The main points:

  • Flat-rate $7 Trades
  • Only $500 to Open an Account
  • Outstanding Customer Service
  • Solid Research Tools

When I am helping people choose an online broker, the only thing I do not like about Scottrade is their speed at which they process your trades. I almost made a youtube video on it once just because it got so frustrating, and it is a simple fix for them too, upgrade your servers!! Their site is slllloooowwwwww! Now, perhaps things have changed since two months ago, but enough was enough for me. If you are a daytrader this will drive you nuts.

On the positive side though, their Scottrade Elite service is pretty cool, and a valuable asset for any experience trader. Scottrade is not publicly traded, and is a privately held corporation. Their customer service is outstanding, they have a China division, and they are definitely a top player in the online broker market with their few million plus customers.

3. Etrade

Etrade is another online broker ranked in the elite. Last I checked they have over 4.3 million clients which I am sure continues to climb steadily each day, and you can trade for as low as $6.99 depending on your account. The main deal with Etrade is they are one of the big brokers leading the way into the home mortgages business, offering checking accounts, credit cards, and the works. Etrade highlights include:

  • 24/7 Help with everything from phone to professional investment guidance
  • 7,000 mutual funds with low commissions
  • Low rates on mortgages, home equity, and margin loans
  • Nearly $180 Billion in customer assets
  • International

I recall the recent push by the big three online brokers for account security, Etrade lead this as well. When it comes to protecting your assets while they sit in your trading account, encryption keys were 2nd hand to what Etrade offered. Overall Etrade is another solid broker with a lot to offer, and they have definitely earned every bit of positive feedback they have received over the years since going public in 1996 under symbol ETFC.

4. ShareBuilder

ShareBuilder leads the industry when it comes to automatic investing plans. Most people know ShareBuilder by their $4 commissions on trading, but don’t be caught up in the hype, there is a catch. To take advantage of the $4, you need to be on one of their automatic investing plans. They have done a great job though of catering to this market and house some good features:

  • Retirement Accounts
  • Automatic Investing Plans
  • Research Tools to explore stocks and ETFs

Now, I can’t say personally what I really think about their services as I have not held an account yet with ShareBuilder, but for those that I have spoken to, they were content overall. If you aren’t in the game though for automatic investing plans are a bit more serious then you won’t find me recommending you to these guys. ShareBuilder is more hands off than the other brokers.

5. OptionsXpress

The last of the brokers covered in this list is OptionsXpress. These guys also have automatic investing plans available for their clients, and with OptionsXpress you can actually buy partial shares. Their low commissions have no hidden fees unlike ShareBuilder, and can be highlighted by:

  • Tools including streaming quotes, real-time charting, strategy scan, and the dragon
  • 5 minute account setup (though I think you can accomplish this elsewhere fairly easily)
  • Financial Liability backed by $500,000 account protection
  • Account Security

Now, a lot of this is really mumbo jumbo when comparing to the brokers above. Account security, research tools, account setup, etc. are all 2nd hand to most of the above brokers. I know that OptionsXpress has international offices which is pretty cool, and I would imagine they would be good for trading, well, options naturally. Beyond this information I cannot say whether or not these guys are any good, but they definitely have a massive marketing budget, so I am assuming they are doing something right.

If you enjoyed this post, make sure to subscribe to the feed!

Related Posts:


Filed Under Online Brokers |
Subscribe to the Blog | Recieve Blog Updates by Email!

----------------------------------------

Share Your Knowledge »

Comment by admound Subscribed to comments via email
2007-05-31 20:42:59
I recently switched from from Scottrade to Fidelity. The main reason was that I don’t usually keep most my money invested at all times because I like to pick and choose shorter term trades. My non-invested money at Fidelity earns 4.98% APY. Scottrade is in the 3’s and I believe they just recently raised it. In this regard, TD Ameritrade seems really low (2.9% apy max if over 200K) and I haven’t found anyone who can match fidelity in this aspect. Not sure about etrade. Something to keep in mind if you are like me. Oh, and Sharebuilder sucks.
Comment by Blain
2007-06-02 20:48:20
“Oh, and Sharebuilder sucks” What was your experience?
 
 
2007-06-01 10:37:29
[…] list of the top 5 online stock brokers and their best attributes.read more | digg […]
 
2007-06-02 16:31:07
Blain, do you have any experience with Interactive Brokers? Around here, they are certainly the lowest cost online brokerage.
Comment by Blain
2007-06-02 20:49:20
I have actually heard pretty good things about Interactive Brokers, no complaints for sure. For Canada I can imagine they are pretty well known, what other brokers are well known up there?
2007-06-04 14:22:16
The 5 big banks all offer brokerage accounts. In terms of non bank brokerages, the popular ones are: Interactive Brokers, E-Trade, Questrade, the credit unions, and Shareowner.
 
 
 
2007-06-02 20:35:06
[…] 5 Top Online Stock Brokers - A list of top five online stock brokers and their best attributes. See what the big boys have to offer. […]
 
2007-06-11 01:00:40
It all depends on what you’re gonna be trading. If you’re just trading stocks and options, I don’t think any of them are gonna be bad, probably all deliver about the same. So you might as well go with who ever does it the cheapest!
 
2007-06-20 23:11:27
[…] should have explained this in my post of the top 5 online stock brokers, but now that I am writing about it, a full post should be dedicated to what are called “Flat […]
 
2007-07-06 18:34:03
[…] to lower their prices. Finally, the Internet made trading much easier and less expensive, and online brokers like E-Trade and Ameritrade competed to deliver even lower […]
 
2007-07-08 12:02:36
[…] Top 5 Online Brokers - Faulkin shares information on OptionsXpress, one of the newest online brokers to enter the competitive brokerage firm market. I’ve considered investing in their company; they trade as OXPS. […]
 
2007-08-02 05:01:14
[…] are many different ways you can trade stocks online with an online broker. Investment strategies come in all different shapes and forms and can integrate both technical and […]
 
Comment by Matt Wolfe
2007-08-11 15:29:37
I hated E-Trade. If you own anything that you just want to sit on for a while or spend some time not actively trading, you get hit with all sorts of “account maintenance fees”. Not to mention it was costing $15 a trade. I switched to Scottrade. $7 Trades, no maintenance fees if you want to sit on things for a while and really great customer service…
Comment by Blain
2007-08-12 02:14:17
Ya actually I found this out recently and it kind of bugged me. To quality for the $6.99 trades you have to have like a $5ok account and trade xx times a month or something ridiculous. Definitely designed for the very active trader.
 
 
Comment by Matthew Subscribed to comments via email
2007-08-15 13:38:04
Can someone help - I’m looking not for a broker but just a service provider that offers real-time streaming market data… Any ideas? Thanks!
Comment by Blain
2007-08-19 21:43:32
Emailed ya cool
 
 
Comment by BrokerSpy Subscribed to comments via email
2007-08-22 07:50:13
Sogoinvest offers stock trading at $3 per trade. The strategies of fractional share investing, compound return, diversification, and dollar cost averaging, which are essential in a long-term investment plan are some of the features which make sogoinvest stand out from others.Whether you are a beginner or expert, this broker offers you everything.
 
2007-08-22 14:42:52
i agree - i’ve had great experience with TDA. i tried opening an account with Zecco but couldn’t even get past that stage for 2 weeks. TDA takes 15 mins online.
 
Comment by Aaron
2007-08-28 12:56:19
I have both TDAmeritrade and ETrade accounts. I use the Ameritrade account more because of the cheaper commissions. ETrade definitely has better research of stocks and mutual funds, but unless you have a lot of money in the account, there is no discount on trading commissions.
 
Trackback by GrowYourFunds
2007-08-28 19:39:14
The Top 5 Online Brokers Tonight I wanted to take a look at some of the top online brokers that investors should look at when opening an account online. There are numerous online brokers out there for investors to research, but not all of them…
 
2007-09-01 12:59:00
[…] 5 Top Online Stock Brokers […]
 
2007-09-05 17:03:12
[…] the charting software will tie in news and fundamental data. I personally use TD Ameritrade as my top stock broker, and they have a decent layout. The best part about taking advantage of the free charting tools […]
 
2007-09-06 06:50:17
[…] every loan, there is an interest rate for what you borrow. In the case of the stock market, your online stock broker typically will charge somewhere around 8% a year on borrowed funds (depending on how much capital […]
 
Comment by Kavit Haria
2007-09-08 14:51:52
I’m in the UK and signed up with Etrade, the UK branch. It costs £8.95 to make a trade. Expensive, but one of the cheapest I’ve found. Thanks for the heads up.
 
2007-09-24 16:19:10
[…] 5 Top Online Stock Brokers […]
 
Comment by Pavel G.
2007-09-26 18:02:50
I have Ameritrade and they are not so hot. I am not satisfied with their “command center” software that they use to help monitor the market (like eSignal). It’s very slow and kills my computer memory, lots of hiccups. My computer is a pretty decent gaming computer and should run this stuff just fine. I actually pay $125 a month to get eSignal and it works like a dream, charts and tons of quotes, it never slows my computer down and works flawlessly. So the blame is on Ameritade for poor optimization of their software. Also, not sure if this is standard but the 3 day buy settle is really annoying because if I sell before 3 days, my money is just held up and I can’t get into another position. They have way too many restrictions on certain things, but I am sure they aren’t the only ones.
 
Comment by Jason Subscribed to comments via email
2007-10-01 16:48:08
I have been momentum trading with Scottrade Elite. Everything is real-time and the charting/layout possibilities are almost endless. However, I have run into problems with hot stocks experiencing heavy volume and not being able to sell short. A message comes up that no short shares are available or, for example, only 50 shares are available when I want to short 1,000. Scottrade says I can call the branch and they can try to locate short shares from other sources, but this is not always convenient. Are there other trading companies that don’t/won’t have this problem because I am considering switching? It is a shame because everything else about Scottrade is fantastic.
Comment by Blain
2007-10-01 17:40:06
Ya know I have found this same problem with TD Ameritrade. Sometimes there simply just aren’t any shares available to short on certain stocks. I think that this all boils down to your timing and the stock because to be able to short your broker has to borrow shares against someone else’s account (I think I said that correctly). So, basically the bigger the network of portfolios the better your odds of getting shares to short. That is my understanding atleast, and thus if you are trying to short a stock that everyone is already actively selling and shorting then your odds of getting shares to short are slim.
 
 
2007-10-01 20:00:41
[…] 5 Top Online Stock Brokers […]
 
Comment by Cody Staub
2007-10-02 15:49:50
I was just looking up comparisons of online brokers as I found this article. Good read, great comparisons. Thanks.
 
2007-10-03 05:59:06
i’m just curious why you didn’t include IB (interactivebrokers) as one of the top 5 … IB can easily beats those on your list … anyway you might have your own reason but still … cheers …
 
Comment by yourtradingstock Subscribed to comments via email
2007-10-03 11:10:47
Blain, Do you think you’ll ever review prop trading firms, or the direct access trading companies? I’d have to agree with the previous post by stocktube… IB is a much better platform if you’re serious about trading. I have a trading buddy who still uses etrade, and I have an acct. too. Yet, you can’t beat the margin prop trading firms allow, or the speed and low commissions of direct access. Mike
 
Comment by yourtradingstock Subscribed to comments via email
2007-10-03 21:44:10
Blain, When I’m referring to direct access, I’m basically targeting online brokers that use realtick, esignal, IB type platforms. As for prop trading firms, there are many, with many options. Heres a post on a list of firms Trader’s Narrative put together. http://www.tradersnarrative.com/list-of-proprietary-trading-firms-735.html One of my trading buddies just started using a prop firm. He has up to 50x margin. You can see the advantage of that. With just $5,000, you could have 250k in buying power. Of course, they won’t just hand you that type of buying power without restrictions in place. Mike Mike
Comment by Blain
2007-10-04 01:28:25
Craziness, thanks for posting this info, I never knew that kind of leverage even existed twisted
 
 
Trackback by Market Flavor Blog
2007-10-04 16:27:03
How to Invest in the Stock Market Step 1 - Sign up with a Stock BrokerWe recommend using a reputable online broker. They are easy to use…
 
Comment by Bubs
2007-10-05 18:12:48
I’m surprised no one mentioned Tradestation. I’ve been using them for about 11 months and its great. I probably only use 5% of the features and can’t imagine using anything else. Their order matrix and radar screen is great for active traders.
 
2007-10-09 18:24:31
[…] 5 Top Online Stock Brokers […]
 
2007-10-11 13:14:25
[…] 5 Top Online Stock Brokers […]
 
 
Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Subscribe to comments via email
mrgreen neutral arrow idea ? ! -) roll twisted evil cry oops razz mad lol cool ??? shock eek sad smile grin
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong> in your comment.
(Please Note: if this is your first comment, it will have to be approved before appearing publicly.)